A friend recently mentioned that she’s planning to bring her listening skills to her upcoming family gatherings over the holidays. Those lovely intentions inspired me to write about what I’ve learned, what I try to do, and what I sometimes (more often than not) still fail at doing. Yet since getting back up and trying again is how we learn, I wrote this for all of us dedicated listeners, who are still trying to figure it out….
I’ll start with “constructively avoiding conflict,” a topic whch sometimes gets a bad rap. Yet sometimes, it can absolutely be the best thing to do. Sometimes we just want to share an enjoyable time with family, especially folks we care about whom we don’t get to see very often. We don’t need to be talking about our differences all the time… and still, there’s an art to avoiding conflict with integrity, without making ourselves invisible.
A. Constructively avoiding conflict, while respecting ourselves and others
Sometimes, for some of us, the honorable intention of avoiding conflict leads us to erase ourselves, and that’s NOT a good thing. So here are a few examples of how we might skillfully avoid conflict, while also showing up for ourselves. For instance, it can be perfectly honorable thing to respond to a provocative comment with,
“Well, I imagine we all have different opinions about that… could you please pass the cranberry sauce? And… what movie have you most enjoyed seeing lately?”
In other words,
a) acknowledging difference, and
b) changing the subject.
Some of us can be very good at jumping right to “step b,” and switching the conversation to other topics. Changing the subject is a useful skill to have. Yet if we don’t take a measured moment for “step a”, acknowledging the differences, the effect can be to silence ourselves and make ourselves invisible. Then we often end up resentful, complaining to friends afterward that others felt so free to share their own controversial political opinions, as though everyone at the table agreed with them…
Channeling Miss Manners here, I am not saying, that we ourselves have to behave in the same thoughtless way. And we also don’t have to jump into the conversation right then and there, either. So between the two extremes of “taking the bait” on the one hand, and just erasing ourselves on the other, there is a middle way…
“That’s a really interesting conversation that I’d love to have with you another time… [assuming we really mean that, of course.] Could you pass the gravy, please? And how is your new grandchild doing?”
Or if we really DON’T want to have that conversation later on…
“Wow! That’s one perspective, for sure! We’d probably need to call in some referees, to be able to have a constructive conversation on that topic [said lightly, with a smile… 🙂 ]. In the meantime, I heard you have some lovely photos from your last vacation…”
B. Some of the basic principles that underlie the above examples of “constructive avoidance”:
1. Challenging conversations work best when both parties are prepared and choosing to enter them. That includes us. We have a choice. It’s perfectly honorable to choose to NOT enter into a conversation on a controversial topic if we don’t have the energy for it, or if it’s just not a good situation, or if we simply choose not to, right then. (Of course, if someone wants to have a difficult conversation with us and it’s never a good time to do so, that’s a different story.)
2. In the long run, it usually doesn’t work well to completely erase ourselves. Instead, we can find polite ways to acknowledge out loud that we have a different perspective, and then change the subject.
Some folks will say, “but they already know that I have a different perspective on the topic…” Well, maybe they need to be reminded? If they are giving voice to their beliefs in front of us, even if they “already know that I have a different perspective”, it’s perfectly fine to remind them, without jumping into the topic itself right then and there. (If we do want to talk with them about it, that’s what the next section is about… 🙂 )
3. We don’t need to become martyrs. Encouraging someone to go on and on about a sensitive or charged topic on which we have a different perspective, while we do our best to listen to them endlessly, is a recipe for resentment, disaster, or both.
4. The one/two sequence of a) acknowledging difference and b) asking them a question about something else, can be a good way to signal that we care about them as a person, and that we are interested in their lives, even as we also respect ourselves enough to acknowledge that we do have a different perspective, one that we are choosing to not get into right now.
Which brings us to the flip side… how to have a productive conversation on a difficult topic, when both parties are choosing to do so?
C. Engaging constructively with differences, while respecting ourselves and others
I want to start by saying that everything in this section, I learned from Dr. David Campt. I used to be one of those folks who would either change the subject with a forced smile on my face, or else do my best to listen endlessly, till I just had to run out of the room to go to the bathroom or something. And then I’d wonder why my “listening” had not worked…
Don’t get me wrong; as a skilled facilitator, I was already at ease helping rooms full of people have constructive conversations on challenging topics. But when I was a participant in a family conversation, and there was no designated facilitator on hand, and I had to somehow figure out how to take on both roles? Now THAT was hard….
So here’s what I learned from David that rocked my world and changed how I understand “dialogue”. I am not claiming to be perfect at this, not by a long shot. But at least I know now, what I’m working toward, and what realistic and effective “listening” can look like…
The short form is as follows. If it’s a good time to have a constructive conversation about a controversial subject, and you’ve both agreed to do so, here’s the play list:
1) Ask a question about how someone came to have a certain belief.
2) Listen. As in, really listen, but for a reasonably short and bounded period of time. Not longer than, say, 5 minutes. You don’t need to time it.
3) Ask if it’s ok to reflect back what you have heard, to check your understanding.
4) Reflect Back. Assuming they say yes, let them know what you heard, in a genuinely appreciative and empathic manner. Check with them to see if they feel heard. Then,
5) Offer one or two authentic points of connection. More about this below. Take a small pause and then,
6) Ask if they would be willing to listen to you, as you share a brief story of how you came to have a different perspective on this particular issue.
7) Assuming they say yes, share a brief story about what influenced you to believe or behave differently.
8) Thank them for listening to you.
Remember to quit while you’re ahead. At this point, if you’ve gone through this 8-step cycle, you have both listened to each other briefly, about a particular topic. Let them know that you’d love to have another conversation with them at another point (assuming that’s true).
Caution: Remind yourself, that you are in this for the long haul – DON’T try to have the other person listen to you about every single area on which the two of you differ, all in a single conversation. Or vice-versa.
How David defines a “win”: a conversation in which you have both listened to each other, and both shared some of your perspectives on a given topic, AND, that has left both of you open to having another conversation with each other, at some future point.
D. More on the steps for engaging differences constructively
Some of the above steps may seem self-explanatory. Here are some notes on the ones that may not be so apparent at first glance.
On step 4, reflecting back what you have heard. If you have a hunch that you’d benefit from some more practice with this incredibly helpful connection-building skill, I highly recommend checking out EmpathyCircles.com for free online circles.
You don’t need to start with one of their free Empathy Circle facilitator trainings. Just sign up to attend a free circle as a participant. You’ll get plenty of practice….and many of us find it to be a super enjoyable community-building practice. Think gummy-bear vitamins. Even attending a single circle will leave you in better shape for holiday conversations with family.
Note: these Empathy Circles were started by Edwin Rutsch. They are not formally connected with David’s work. David just assumes that we all already have this basic skill in place. Edwin thinks the world will be a better place, once many of us DO have this basic skill in place. So he and others are working hard to help make it happen!
On step 5, offering an authentic point of connection. David recommends preparing ahead for this one. What are some likely controversial topics that might come up? The person who thinks differently from you on this topic… what underlying human need might they be trying to address? For example, on the topic of gun safety: “I hear that protecting yourself and your family is really important to you, and that’s why you feel so strongly about Second Amendment rights. I get that you really care about your family’s safety.”
Just note that you don’t START with this… you start by listening to the other person’s story, and then reflecting it back, and then, assuming they feel heard and understood, sharing an authentic point of connection. Something you can relate to, even if you don’t agree with their solution.
On step 7, offering your own story about how you came to your beliefs. The more personal, the better. We are not trying to make a legal court case here, and we are not trying to convince the other person about anything. No hammering with facts. Our intention is to connect on a heart level, by sharing how we came to believe the way we do. Bonus points for sharing any authentic doubts along the way.
Well, that’s it… simple, but not easy.
I hope that some of this is helpful for you…
And whether you choose to constructively avoid conflict, or to constructively engage with differences, or to do some of each as appropriate, I wish you a very meaningful and enjoyable holiday season.
With much appreciation,
Rosa